The Night on the May Farm Hill

Folk stories from the Flatwoods Monster tradition — original tales, analysis, and storytelling history


Story One

The Night on the May Farm Hill

This retelling closely follows the widely reported September 12, 1952 account as covered in contemporary press and later researched by UFO historians, rather than being a looser folk legend without a specific documented basis.

Kathleen May's sons and their friends were playing outside in Flatwoods that evening when they saw a bright object streak across the sky and appear to land on a nearby hillside on the May family's property. Excited and alarmed, they ran to tell Kathleen May, and the group — now including National Guardsman Eugene Lemon, who happened to be nearby — decided to investigate together, bringing flashlights and, in Lemon's case, a firearm.

As they climbed the hill, the group reported a strange mist settling around them and an increasingly strong, sickening odor. Lemon's flashlight beam reportedly fell on a massive, dark shape near a tree, which resolved into a tall figure with a metallic-seeming, spade-shaped head and brightly glowing eyes.

By most accounts, the figure appeared to glide or move toward the group, and panic broke out immediately — the group fled back down the hill and to safety, several reporting nausea, throat irritation, and continued fear well after returning home.

The story spread quickly through the small community and then into regional and national press within days, cementing the Flatwoods encounter as one of the most immediately and widely reported cryptid cases of its era, rather than a story that developed slowly through word of mouth over years.

Story 2

The Flashlight Failure

A specific and frequently discussed detail in witness accounts is that Eugene Lemon's flashlight reportedly dimmed or failed at the critical moment the group's light fell on the creature, plunging the group briefly into greater darkness right as the most frightening part of the encounter occurred. Some researchers have pointed to this as a mundane but significant contributing factor — a malfunctioning flashlight in near-total darkness, combined with adrenaline and fear, creating exactly the conditions under which an ordinary animal could be badly misperceived.

Other researchers and some witnesses have instead cited the flashlight failure as additional evidence of something genuinely anomalous at the scene, consistent with widely reported (though scientifically unverified) claims across UFO folklore more broadly that electronic equipment often malfunctions near reported sighting locations.

What Do These Stories Mean?

The flashlight detail is a useful illustration of how the same specific fact can be marshaled as evidence by both skeptical and believer interpretations of the same case — a recurring pattern across many well-documented cryptid and UFO incidents where the ambiguity of a single detail becomes a focal point for competing explanations.

How These Stories Are Told

Unlike most entities on this site, the Flatwoods Monster's 'folklore' consists almost entirely of first-generation witness testimony and near-immediate press coverage rather than generations of oral retelling, giving researchers unusually direct access to original source material rather than having to reconstruct a story from much later, more distorted retellings.